Cacica is what one would expect to see for a woman, although we know of one example where a woman from the Valley of Toluca calls herself a "principala yhuan cacique." (San Pablo Tepemaxalco, Toluca Valley, 1762)
Caterina Pizzigoni, ed., Testaments of Toluca (Stanford: Stanford University Press and UCLA Latin American Center Publications, 2007), 139–40.
Cacique "sometimes had its original meaning, referring to the head of a dynastic lineage and holder of its right, but more often it simply meant a person of considerable wealth with high standing in the indigenous community." (San Pablo Tepemaxalco, Toluca Valley, 1762)
Caterina Pizzigoni, ed., Testaments of Toluca (Stanford: Stanford University Press and UCLA Latin American Center Publications, 2007), 139–40.
nehual notoca Maria Micaela yxpocatl = prenSipala = yhuan CaSique = I named Maria Micaela, unmarried woman, principala and cacique. (San Pablo Tepemaxalco, Toluca Valley, 1762)
Caterina Pizzigoni, ed., Testaments of Toluca (Stanford: Stanford University Press and UCLA Latin American Center Publications, 2007), 139–40.